How do I...?
There are three steps you can follow to evaluate the sources (articles, websites, books) that you have found. You will want to evaluate the credibility of the author, validity of the research, and relevance of articles and web sites.
The first step in evaluating a source is determining the authority of the author who produced the material. To determine authority, you'll want to evaluate the trustworthiness (credentials, education, experience, etc.) of an author.
To determine credibility, ask these questions:
- Is the author formally educated in the subject?
- Does the author work for a university or research center?
- Is the author a recognized scholar in the subject?
- Does the author have an established history of research and writing on the subject?
The second step of evaluating a source is determining the validity of the research being presented in the article, website or book. To ensure that the research is valid, you want to determine the quality of the research used to support the argument being made. It is also important to remember that excellent or persuasive writing doesn't necessarily ensure that the research presented is valid.
To determine the validity of the research in the source, ask these questions:
- Does the author thoroughly cite all the sources? (Saying "a study was done" is not a citation.)
- Is there a list of sources at the end of the article?
- Does the author's evidence support the claim?
- Is the author's evidence objective research instead of personal narrative?
- Does it come from a peer-reviewed publication (which means the research was evaluated by experts before it was published)?
The third step in evaluating a source is determining the article's relevance to your topic:
To determine relevance, ask these questions:
- Is the article sufficiently broad to address the issue you are discussing?
- If the article is broad, can its conclusions be applied to your subject? (e.g. an article about drinking habits of students at large universities applies to your subject of drinking habits of CU students)
- If the article is narrow, can its conclusions be generalized to your subject? (e.g. an article about volleyball players and eating disorders at Honalee State University can be applied to your subject of eating disorders in women college athletes)